Horror. Done Differently.
Ivan Budiwski ©October 2026
This essay will compare three horror movies that are all trying to scare the audience in different ways. Analyzing their differences and finding their similarities, as well as wondering what really makes horror scary.
The three movies that will be compared are: IT, Scream, and Blair Witch Project. Three different films trying different methods to scare the viewer. This paper will compare them by explaining what each movie is trying to do to scare the audience, explaining why it does or doesn’t work and at the end compare the movies in detail.
Scream, and why jumpscares don’t always work.
Scream is a great example of not trying hard enough to be different from its predecessors.
Scream is in the Slasher genre of horror films which are usually associated with masked men, terrorizing and brutally killing groups of friends or even just the whole town in some cases. They usually have a lot of gory kills, and usually end with the last one standing from the victims (usually a girl) figuring out who the killer is one way or another, and killing them right when they slip up. (Quinn, 2026) That’s not always how it is, but it usually is.
Scream’s main plot centralizes around a group of high school friends who are pretty much just typical 80’s teens. Right at the start of the movie, a teenage girl receives a phone call while home alone, from a stranger who flirts with her and just asks her some questions. After the guy on the phone starts raising his voice and threatening to kill her if she hangs up on him, he tells her to look outside, where her boyfriend is strapped to a chair. And with one cut of the porch light, he is brutally gutted. The girl dies shortly after, as Ghost Face (The Killer) breaks into the house and hangs her outside for her parents to see. (Craven, 1997/1997) It was actually a very good opening scene for a slasher film, it had some good tension with quite a bit of unexpectedness.
The main problem comes from the fact that they fully reveal the killer in the first ten minutes of the movie, though they don’t show who’s behind the mask. The thing with slasher films, the goal of the movie isn’t really to defeat the threat, or figure out what its goals are, it’s mainly just to figure out who the man behind the mask is. Which isn’t necessarily bad, but it’s definitely a hindrance to what the movie can do. When the goal of the characters is just to rip off the killer’s mask, and live to tell the tale, it really doesn’t make sense why the movie lasts more than thirty minutes.
On another note, these films don’t tend to be scary on their own, due to a random guy in a mask not being very scary. So they rely heavily or in some cases entirely on jumpscares to scare the audience. While jumpscares do get a reaction out of most people, it only scares you the first time. All animals have a fear response, it’s how they stay alive when a predator is nearby. Humans are no different, it’s just that our fear response is triggered less often due to humans living in much safer conditions than most other animals. (Marshall, 2025) Jumpscares trigger one’s fear response by throwing a threat in their face unexpectedly, causing fear, but a jumpscare only works once or twice before it doesn’t even faze you anymore. Which is why most slasher films (Like Scream) get old really quick. Now I’m not saying jumpscares are bad, quite the opposite actually, but they don’t work if it’s all you rely on to scare your audience.
One final thing of note, is that most slasher films greatly lack that sense of uneasiness that a lot of other genres of horror have. For example, in a slasher film you know 100% that the killer isn’t gonna show up in the middle of the day, or at the police station. Other genres aren’t limited by that; however, like in the movie Alien, the movie fills you with a large amount of uneasiness by not really giving the Xenomorph any limits to where it can and can’t go. The movie takes place on a spaceship where the crew can’t leave. When the Xenomorph breaks on board, it has completely free reign of the ship and can appear anywhere at any time. (Scott, 1979/1979).
IT, and cosmic horror done right.
For the purpose of convenience both IT: Chapter 1 and Chapter 2 will be joined together, along with information from the original books as well.
Cosmic horror is widely different from jumpscares or big monsters in the woods, though to keep it brief. Cosmic horror is the type of horror that makes your reality, everything you know and ever will know feel insignificant. That our reality is merely the fingertip of a much larger thing. (Langan, 2023) IT, is a great example of cosmic horror done right.
Pennywise in the first film is portrayed as a tall lanky clown, with demonic yellow eyes and
abnormally large smile. He can stretch his face and his body in extremely disturbing ways, and his voice always sounds unsettling no matter the situation. He is something that the kids (the protagonists) can’t possibly understand, since at the start of the movie Pennywise is shown to torment the kids of Derry (The town the film takes place in)by showing them illusions of their pasts and forcing them face to face with their greatest fears. Already Pennywise is an immensely powerful being. Being able to shapeshift, seemingly trap people within their own minds, as well as the illusions mentioned earlier. And the reason this scares us more than classic slasher films, is due to the fact that it’s something that we don’t understand. This is a being whose motives are almost completely unknown. Humans are naturally afraid of the unknown, a dark room that you’ve never entered before, is a lot scarier than a dark room you have been in. (Robson, 2021).
Pennywise’s goals are never fully explained anywhere so it forces you to speculate to think ofwhat this being could want, which causes your mind to waver. Even if you do somehow begin to understand his goals (which you can’t really do until the end of Chapter 2), that comfort of knowledge fades fast once you realize that he’s just a mask for the real monster; The Deadlights. The Deadlights are as described in several of Stephen King’s (the author of IT) books: Are an extremely deadly and mysterious ancient form of eldritch energy, known as a living infinite realm within the empty void between dimensions. They consist of endless twisting bright orange lights. It is known in universe that one glance at the Deadlights can be fatal, or lead to permanent insanity.
In fact, in one of Stephen King’s books, Insomnia. (King, 1994, #) It is implied that looking into the Deadlights is a face worse than death itself. So the Deadlights are so incomprehensible that they had to make a physical body just to interact with mortals. Humans are naturally scared of things they don’t understand, so when you’re faced with a guy in a mask trying to stab you, you’re scared but not because the guy is scary, you’re scared because he’s actively trying to kill you. But Pennywise never shows to be actively trying to kill the main cast at all in the first film, which makes the majority of the film’s fear factor come from Pennywise just being scary in ways we can’t comprehend.
On top of all of this, while you’re watching, you’re almost constantly expecting something due to Pennywise being able to appear at any moment. (guy, 2008).
In the finale of IT: Chapter 2, the main characters band together to kill Pennywise and the
Deadlights once and for all. (Muschietti, 2017) When they did succeed, it felt real, it didn’t feel like plot armor. Plot armor is where the writers come up with a moment that one hundred percent should stop or harm a character in some way, but fails to do so due to the writers realizing that they can’t kill off the character. Though instead of just taking out the scene that should kill them, they just write that they survive even if it makes no sense. They are literally protected by the plot. (Salao) One more example of this is in the finale of Stranger Things Season 5, where the main cast is facing off against Vecna and The Mind Flayer. By all accounts they should have lost, but the writers had to make them win in someway, so they just cut out all the parts that would stop the protagonists, like Vecna’s army which is just completely absent in the finale altogether, purely because if they weren’t, the heroes would have lost. (Duffer & Duffer, 2016/2025).
Pennywise’s defeat made sense. They fixed cosmic horrors’ biggest problem: “How do you defeat something that isn’t able to be defeated?” Even after they kill Pennywise, the Deadlights are still out there somewhere in the universe. All it takes is them falling back to earth.
Blair Witch Project, and how it shows fear.
The Blair Witch Project is called a Found Footage horror film. Found footage films are
designed to make the whole movie feel like raw unedited footage of the characters recording the events. Making it seem like you really are watching the last moments of real people. (Eldridge & Ostberg).
Blair Witch Project does this extremely well and apparently it’s the most notable piece of found footage horror. This movie really makes you feel uneasy or scared all the time. The characters in this film are just some normal college students making a documentary about an urban legend, the Blair Witch. The film builds up the Blair Witch by showing the protagonists interviewing different residents of the town and getting their takes on the myth.
The people describe cops finding mutilated bodies in the woods, people being tortured in a little shack, but one person supposedly saw the witch, and described it as a hairy being with a feminine body, but covered to head and toe with brown fur. Throughout the movie the Blair Witch kind of stalks the three students by following them through the woods, but it never seems to act until the end. In fact, it never even reveals itself for the entire movie, that’s right the monster in this horror film you never even see! (Myrick & Sanchez, 1999/1999).
You’d think that would be counter intuitive but the main fear of this film is from how real it all seems. It scares you by thrusting the characters into an incredibly real situation (getting lost in the woods) and then twists that situation, slowly turning into something supernatural. Throughout the film, you can’t help but empathize with the characters. They’ve been lost in the woods for 3 days, slowly running out of supplies, and with zero hope of escape once they lose their map to an argument. Almost every night the characters hear noises and weird structures being built in the night by something they can never see.
It gets even worse when one night one night after they start fighting amongst each other that one of them goes missing. The next night, his organs are sitting outside their tent, wrapped in his shirt. Then when they stumble across a ruined house in the night they get picked off. Though you never see what really happens, the movie portrays this as almost real events. A threat you can’t see or even face is a lot scarier because you never know how to deal with it until it’s too late.
The Comparison
IT, Scream, and Blair Witch Project, are all different movies but they’re all trying to scare its
audience. IT, uses a cosmic deity that can never truly be stopped. Scream, uses a normal guy in a mask to pop out at unexpected times. Finally, The Blair Witch Project has a creature we know absolutely nothing about.
Scream’s, reliance on cheap jumpscares to scare the audience works on paper, but not very well in practice. Doing the same thing to scare your audience over and over again is not effective at all. Repetition and Horror don’t mix, so forcing them to mix gives you something that’s hard to tell if it’s actually trying to be scary or not. (Marshall, 2025).
Compare that to IT’s, fantastic use of cosmic horror, and very little jumpscares make it feel less like a movie that’s trying to scare you, and more of something that’s scary by default. An intergalactic entity is a lot scarier than a guy with a knife, even if it’s less realistic. Another thing of note, is that IT’s, antagonist (Pennywise) feels like a genuine threat to the safety of humanity, while Ghost Face from Scream gets trounced on time and time again by drunk teens. Sure Pennywise lost to kids, but that’s because they figured out his weakness not because they beat him with raw strength.
The only thing holding IT, back in terms of horror, is the fact that they completely show off the monster in the first thirty minutes. Now that’s not necessarily a bad thing if you do other things to compensate, but IT, sadly, didn’t, which stops it from being a ten out of ten.
The Blair Witch Project compared to the likes of Scream and IT, is a much scarier movie. First off, the film doesn’t make the mistake of revealing the monster early, in fact, they take it one step further and never showing it at all. Not having a visible threat makes your brain try to locate and identify the danger, but it ultimately fails leaving you with a large portion of missing information, like having only ninety-nine out of a hundred pieces of a puzzle.
That’s not the only thing Blair Witch Project does better than IT, and Scream. It also shoves the characters in a more down to earth situation making the whole film much more relatable. On the other hand, it does do some things worse than the other films. For starters, not having a clear visual representation of your antagonist makes it a lot harder to identify the film as a whole, Pennywise and Ghost Face are both extremely iconic now-a-days.
Conclusion
All three of these films tried different approaches to horror, and some of them are better at it than others. And at the end of the day none of these are bad movies or bad horror movies, it’s all up to personal opinion which one you think is scarier. You might get scared of continuous jumpscares and loud sound effects or you might not.
Now in terms of overall Horror. The Blair Witch Project is the scariest one on the
scientific/technical side of things, while the better movie over all is probably IT. None of these movies are bad horror movies. At the end of the day Horror is just what scares you as a person. But scientifically speaking The Blair Witch Project should scare you more than any other horror movie on this list, by a long shot.
Ivan Budiwski, Grade 10, October 2026

References
Craven, W. (Director). (1997). Scream [Film]. STARZ.
https://www.primevideo.com/detail/0JXFGTDLEOOLFR4B9ZPEX9K4JD (Original work published 1997)
Duffer, M., & Duffer, R. (Creators). (2025). Stranger Things [TV series]. Netflix.
https://www.netflix.com/ca/title/80057281 (Original work published 2016)
Eldridge, S., & Ostberg, R. (???). Found footage | Definition, Movies, History, & Facts. Britannica. Retrieved October
10, 2026, from https://www.britannica.com/art/found-footage
guy, a. (2008). What is Suspense? Writer’s Digest. Retrieved October 10, 2026, from
https://www.writersdigest.com/mystery-thriller/what-is-suspense
King, S. (1994). Insomnia. Viking Press. https://stephenking.com/works/novel/insomnia.html
Langan, J. (2023). What Is Cosmic Horror in Fiction? Writer’s Digest. Retrieved October 9, 2026, from
https://www.writersdigest.com/write-better-fiction/what-is-cosmic-horror-in-fiction
Marshall, L. (2025). ‘Jump scare’ science: Study explains how the brain responds to fear. University of Colorado
Boulder. Retrieved October 9, 2026, from
https://www.colorado.edu/today/2025/10/30/jump-scare-science-study-explains-how-brain-responds-fear
Muschietti, A. (Director). (2017). IT [Film]. HBO MAX.
https://www.primevideo.com/detail/0KZXLKBUCDP3YPF5UCGEXY5KWJ (Original work published 2017)
Myrick, D., & Sanchez, E. (Directors). (1999). The Blair Witch Project [Film]. Lions gate.
https://www.primevideo.com/detail/0NMVSUL9FYBH8ED326LSYKN7DI (Original work published 1999)
Quinn, E. (2026, March 2nd). What is Slasher Horror? Medium. Retrieved October 10th, 2026, from
https://medium.com/never-stop-writing/what-is-slasher-horror-eb6c672dbe90
Robson, D. (2021). Why we’re so terrified of the unknown. BBC. Retrieved October 9, 2026, from
https://www.bbc.com/worklife/article/20211022-why-were-so-terrified-of-the-unknown
Salao, C. (???). Plot Armor: What It Is and How to believably protect your characters. TCK Publishing.
https://www.tckpublishing.com/plot-armor/
Scott, R. (Director). (1979). Alien [Film]. Twentieth century fox.
https://www.primevideo.com/detail/0LGXVI6RCHFOE7YL6HOZC3PE6R (Original work published 1979)
